2025. 1. 26. 21:45ㆍStudy Abroad and Jobs
When selecting an engineering university in the United States, students and parents often refer to various ranking organizations. Among them, the QS World University Rankings and US News & World Report are two of the most trusted sources worldwide. This article compares the engineering university rankings from these two organizations, analyzing their strengths and differences.
Table of Contents
- Differences in Evaluation Criteria
- 2025 Engineering University Rankings Comparison (QS vs US News)
- Key Differences Analysis
- Which Ranking Should You Refer To?
- Conclusion
1. Differences in Evaluation Criteria
QS World University Rankings
QS evaluates universities based on global reputation and research performance, incorporating the following factors:
- Academic Reputation (40%): A global survey of academics about research and teaching quality.
- Employer Reputation (10%): Employers' perceptions of graduates' employability.
- Citations per Faculty (20%): Measures research impact.
- Faculty-to-Student Ratio (20%): Reflects the quality of education.
- International Student and Faculty Ratio (10%): Indicates the level of global engagement.
US News & World Report
US News focuses primarily on U.S. institutions and considers the following criteria:
- Undergraduate and Graduate Program Reputation (25%): Evaluated by academic and industry experts.
- Research Activity and Funding (30%): Includes research grants, publications, etc.
- Graduate Success (20%): Measures initial career success and average salaries of graduates.
- Student Resources (15%): Includes faculty, labs, and library facilities.
- Student Achievement (10%): Includes average GPA and standardized test scores of incoming students.
2. 2025 Engineering University Rankings Comparison (QS vs US News)
QS World University Rankings (Engineering & Technology)
- MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
- Stanford University
- University of Cambridge
- UC Berkeley (University of California, Berkeley)
- University of Oxford
- Caltech (California Institute of Technology)
- ETH Zurich
- Imperial College London
- National University of Singapore (NUS)
- Carnegie Mellon University
US News & World Report (Best Engineering Schools)
- MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
- Stanford University
- UC Berkeley (University of California, Berkeley)
- Georgia Institute of Technology
- Caltech (California Institute of Technology)
- University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
- Carnegie Mellon University
- University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
- Purdue University
- University of Texas at Austin
3. Key Differences Analysis
- Global vs. Domestic Focus
- QS evaluates universities worldwide, emphasizing international prestige, while US News primarily focuses on U.S. institutions.
- For example, QS rankings feature UK (Oxford, Cambridge), Switzerland (ETH Zurich), and Singapore (NUS) universities in the top tier.
- Weight of Reputation
- QS assigns significant weight to academic and employer reputation (50%).
- US News places more emphasis on research performance and resource allocation.
- Emphasis on Research vs. Practical Outcomes
- US News evaluates practical outcomes like employment rates, salaries, and research funding.
- QS focuses on the international impact of research.
4. Which Ranking Should You Refer To?
For Global Aspirations:
QS rankings are beneficial for students seeking international opportunities and networking in a globally recognized academic environment.
For U.S.-Focused Career Goals:
US News rankings are ideal for those planning to work or pursue research in the U.S., as they emphasize local strengths and graduate success.
5. Conclusion
QS and US News provide rankings based on different criteria. It’s important to consider your goals and preferences when using these rankings. For engineering majors, research performance, career support, and networking opportunities are key factors to evaluate.
If you have more questions, leave a comment or subscribe to the blog for updates!